Consultation over Alexander First School in Windsor closure goes ahead

Campaigners attending the meeting. <i>(Image: Elena Chiujdea, Local Democracy Reporting Service)</i>
Campaigners attending the meeting. (Image: Elena Chiujdea, Local Democracy Reporting Service)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Councillors have agreed that ‘no further action’ will be taken over the Royal Borough’s cabinet decision to consult on a school’s potential closure. 

Last month, the Royal Borough’s cabinet agreed to start a consultation for Alexander First School’s potential closure in Windsor from the end of the 2027/28 academic year.

The decision came back before an adults, children and health overview and scrutiny panel on Monday (16 November) after councillors called in the decision for further scrutiny.

Councillor Carole Da Costa (TBFI, Clewer and Dedworth West), Cllr Wisdom Da Costa (Ind, Clewer and Dedworth West) and Cllr Neil Knowles, the armed forces champion for the Royal Borough, signed the call-in.

Campaigners – including school governors, ward councillors, parents, pupils and teachers – packed into the gallery calling on councillors to ‘save our school’.

Councillor Amy Tisi, the lead member for education, told the Town Hall meeting that agreeing to consult on the potential closure of Alexander First School was ‘a tough decision’.

“But leadership is not about avoiding tough decisions; it’s about confronting those difficult realities and engaging openly with residents,” she added.

She said the cabinet had ‘sufficient information’ to agree to the consultation and delaying it  ‘simply delays the opportunity for people to have their say’.

But Cllr Knowles said the consultation is ‘a bit of a misnomer ’, with the only options being to close the school or not.

Cllr Tisi said ‘the very point’ of a consultation is for residents to comment and suggest alternatives.

All first schools in Windsor were looked at using the same criteria, including parental preference and a school’s finances.

Questions were raised over how much weight each criteria was given when deciding which school would be consulted on for potential closure.

Cllr Carole Da Costa said she didn’t see any weighting given to schools rated as ‘good’ or not.

Ben Wright, the council’s school place planning and capital programme manager, said a school’s Ofsted rating was not included in the metric and instead, attainment was looked at.

Cllr Jack Douglas (TBFI, St Mary’s) said it ‘struck’ him how the weightings worked when it came to a school’s deficit.

“The way the weightings were designed [meant that] the bigger the deficit that lands on RBWM, the more likely that school is to be chosen for closure,” he said.

Alexander First School had the highest deficit, £1.2million, at the end of 2025/26.

The cost of closing the school in 2028/29 is around £2million which will fall on the council, the call-in said.

Mr Wright said: “It’s absolutely true that the closure of Alexander First School in 2028/29 would be the most costly option because you’ve got that highest deficit to get rid of.

“But if you don’t close the school, the deficit will keep on growing and then the impact on council tax and the council’s funding will get ever worse.”

Cabinet papers said all first schools were given the opportunity to comment, but no statements were received.

Mariam Kholar, the headteacher of Alexander First School, said in September she received a seven-minute call informing her the school ranked first for closure.

Mr Wright said the council rang the school to say that ‘unfortunately Alexander First School was at the top of the list’.

First schools were then given two to three weeks to provide a statement and ‘unfortunately that opportunity was not taken’, he added.

Cllr Carole Da Costa asked that the consultation be delayed until all of the missing information is provided and then send the decision back to cabinet.

She said the cabinet report did not consider the Welsh Guards deployment to Cyprus and their return in 2028.

New housing near the school is also being built, and concerns were raised about ‘insufficient local school places’ if Alexander First School is closed.

But Mr Wright said that if further data came along which materially changes the school being consulted on for proposed closure, the consultation process would need to be redone.

Councillors decided to take no further action around the cabinet’s original decision – with four votes for ‘no further action’, two against and one councillor abstaining.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos